[Sherman Logan]

That people with distinctly different genetics might have differences in odor doesn’t seem particularly odd to me, or inherently racist for that matter.

But in America it is so entangled with the assumption that this difference (if it exists) is a symptom of racial inferiority and of course the struggle against such racism that we can’t even discuss whether it might be true.

Logically, a difference in odor is no more evidence of superiority or inferiority than a difference in skin color or height.

As such, whether such a difference exists is a question of fact, and subject to scientific confirmation or disproof.

But of course most of us prefer to proclaim our own moral superiority by demonizing those who have the nerve to comment on their perception of a difference in body odor. (To be fair, some who have this perception deserve the demonization.)

[Robert Teesdale]

That people with distinctly different genetics might have differences in odor doesn’t seem particularly odd to me, or inherently racist for that matter.

I agree, it doesn't. If one were to assert that there was an objective degree of better smell, that would be a different matter.

But in America it is so entangled with the assumption that this difference (if it exists) is a symptom of racial inferiority and of course the struggle against such racism that we can’t even discuss whether it might be true.

It's not "discussable" in society, true.

Logically, a difference in odor is no more evidence of superiority or inferiority than a difference in skin color or height.

I'd suggest that it correlates with things like success, etc. - just as taller and more attractive people tend to be paid more, those that smell better are likely also better compensated. I'd suspect that's a function of hygiene rather than ethnic composition.

As such, whether such a difference exists is a question of fact, and subject to scientific confirmation or disproof.

You're defending your intellectual integrity without need.

But of course most of us prefer to proclaim our own moral superiority by demonizing those who have the nerve to comment on their perception of a difference in body odor. (To be fair, some who have this perception deserve the demonization.)

Well, it's not that complicated, really. If one is honest - and nonideological - it's easy.

1. Different people smell different.

2. Some people smell better than others.

3. Your hygiene mileage may vary.