I believe you misspelled "smart". *grin*
As I mentioned before, the original thread was based upon a claim that Cats Are Better Than Women Because..., and then some jokester replied with a listing of why Dogs Are Better Than Men Because..., and the lists and comments became rather confused after a bit.
The resulting thread with the original, compiled lists together were then reposted on a new thread for clarity, and comments were added to the response from the original posting, thus the replies to the Dog Claims.
Oddly enough, I have yet to see anyone refute either the Cat claims, or the points brought up in responce to the Dog Claims. Strange, n'est ce pas? *snicker*
Ping! (Poke!) *grin* See what you started, Janey? *laugh*