Paul Jolley
His choice is "Eleanor Rigby". It's not half bad.
"It's not half good either."
He throws in a Adam Lambert scream near the end that seems like a Hail Mary pass that misses.
Minaj: I did not like your performance, Jol. Very, very safe. Very bland. And forgettable.
Randy: Wow. Felt like you were disconnected from the song.
Mariah: Great song choice. You have to be able to give as much emotion (consistently through the song, not in spots) You can sing an uptempo dance record. I never understood the Country music thing.
Keith: I wasn't a big fan of the falsetto note at the end. I don't hear the Country thing either.
Pack your bags, Jolley.