[silent_jonny]

Charlie looks like he could be Idols first self inflicted casualty.
Theres something deeply disturbing about him

Yes. After his segment was over I was expecting to hear a gunshot backstage.

When they came back from commercial, Seacrest seemed rattled.

If Charlie is really that down (he could be acting for sympathy votes, who knows) then I hope Idol has someone responsible watching over him, at least for tonight.

[retrokitten]

I don’t think he was faking. I think he’s genuinely a little off.