Nick Boddington
Sings Goo-Goo Dolls' "Iris". Plays piano. It's okay, but not memorable.
Keith: What a perfect song for you. I love you playing the piano and singing. Thought you were really nervous in certain spots. (but he saw through that) You were beautiful tonight.
Minaj: Glad you went back to the piano, you really shine there. It's true to you. Kudos.
Randy: Don't know if it was your best performance. Who are you really? Glad you went back to being you.
Mariah: Felt like you really kicked in at the end. There you were strong and confident. (again hopes voters take previous performances into consideration--that's the kiss of death.)