I loved that show as a kid and remember watching that very program. The host was Gary Moore... a very funny guy. I also remember one with three or four old guys that the panel could not to figure out. They were all former ball players who played in the very first World Series in 1903. I thought it was cool because I knew one of the players name and figured it out by myself.
Gary Moore appeared on the Tonight show with Carson more than a few times too. He was very funny.