[Las Vegas Ron]

Then forget about shot. Slugs are the surest way to get that. Not much stands up to slugs.

I hear that, but in a dark house while maybe still shaking off some sleepiness, would a little spread be a good thing?

A slug requires a definitive hit....but otoh, any hit would be quite debilitating and shocking to the perp.

A lot to consider for a unique situation, I hope and pray neither you or I have to face it.

I guess the best plan is a general one, loads that take all into account and address them in the best, most effective way in a general scenario.

[philman_36]

I hear that, but in a dark house while maybe still shaking off some sleepiness, would a little spread be a good thing?
That's why I suggested a variety of rounds with increasing lethality. I wouldn't even bother with bird shot. Buckshot (2-3) and slugs (remainder).

A lot to consider for a unique situation, I hope and pray neither you or I have to face it.
Yes, it is and nor do I.

I guess the best plan is a general one, loads that take all into account and address them in the best, most effective way in a general scenario.
Being mentally prepared is a big step. Even though you don't want to have to think about it you must.

[GGpaX4DumpedTea]

“I hear that, but in a dark house while maybe still shaking off some sleepiness, would a little spread be a good thing?”

Put a light on that shotgun, and maybe a laser. Important you see the target, both for acquisition and for identification (might not be a bad guy). Alternate the slug with 00 and you will get the job done. The laser is an especially good idea for a pistol grip.

And btw, I believe your home defense semi-auto hand gun should have both light and laser. Many already have the mounting rail under the barrel, in front of the trigger.

In low light situations, with either the shotgun or the hand gun, it is essential that you be able to identifiy the target BEFORE you pull the trigger.