Adding this to the inappropriate list--P2's last song, "We've Got Tonight", is about a one night stand. J-Lo said she bet all the Ferlies in the audience wished he was singing that to them.
"Does he mean a sleep-over?"
The judges really have a gift for hyperbole. Jessica’s version of “I’ll Be There” fell short of the Jacksons’, IMO.
In P2’s defense-he didn’t choose that song-Jimmy did. I didn’t think P2 looked very comfortable singing it either...or maybe he wasn’t feeling well again-hard to tell!