Phillip Phillips
(2nd Song)
Round #2 is Contestant's Choice. Joshua chooses John Lennon's "Imagine". (Speaking of kitchen breaks) This atheist anthem seems like an odd choice for a "son of a preacherman".
But he's not screeching. For that, I give it a marginal ...
Steven: Joshua it was beautiful. Another Thank You, God moment. You are so fine!
J-Lo: A pulled back and controlled performance. It was almost like you were preaching while you were singing. You have an incredible instrument. The way you dig deep into the music and the meaning, that's what makes you special. Courage and strength.
Randy: Everything you sing should touch you and mean something. Every time you sing people feel what you do. Pulled back but still gave us a little Josh at the end.