Cause it's the greatest song ever! Or all the good songs were already taken and she had no choice.
Probably the latter :)
I am still cracking up that most of the contestants thought Joy to the World was just Christmas song LOL!!! (but in all fairness, the cop could have sait “Jeremiah was a bullfrog” to let them know what the hell she was talking about)
In the flashback sequence to previous group nights, was that a "cameoe" by Tatiana?
Seriously, this episode could be AI's "jump the shark" moment? I can't ever recall a single episode where there was not ONE actual performance. There wasn't one tonite. It's becoming more "reality TV" than a competition.
I get the sense that the overall level of talent is far less than last season..