Would do the No Sugar Added except the sugar alcohols are a killer for my system (if ya know what I mean...lol.)
My favorite is Thrifty’s Ice Cream. Rite Aid bought Thrifty drug store a few years ago and they carry the Thrifty Ice Cream.
When I can get it, I like the Mocha Almond Fudge otherwise it is the Butter Pecan. I’m a NUT junkie. LOL