Casey came on the show saying that he was unattractive. I think he was so thrilled to “get” miss Haley that he probably lets her sass him like she did JLo and Randy.
But you are right — JLo is criticizing singers who are really good, when she really can’t sing at all.
Last night when everyone was posting or talking about various versions of I Who have Nothing, I went to youtube and listened to quite a few versions. Bassey, Jones, Sparks, Elvis. That song, one would think would have been a Pia song type, but as hard as I try, I just can’t picture her singing it, because the song requires raw emotion and that’s why Pia was booted imo, she just couldn’t deliver the raw emotions.
I just watched Jordin Sparks version of I Who Have Nothing on youtube. The girl could sing. Big powerful voice and the thing about Jordin as opposed to Haley is that Jordin knew how to tell a story. I remember that girl pouring her heart and soul into a few of her performances. The raw emotion. She FELT the music. That is the mark of a good performer.