Well, it depends on “when” the guy drummed. Hands down, Carmine Appice from 1968 to about 1975 blew any of these people away for ROCK drumming. (I hate Peart and Moon, overplaying and omnipresent egoists as they were). Appice has declined badly, but his drumming in that era was the best, and even Bonham learned most of what he knew from Carmine and said so.
Shaky vid but it tells the story. Man...the memories.