Casey James
This is Kara's choice: John Mayer's "Daughters". Well it's better than that silly song he performed before. But this is too slow-paced and sleepy.
Randy: The first song you did tonight, I wasn't in favor of that. But this song fits you like a glove. Continue in this direction.
Ellen: Really good. I liked that a lot.
Kara: This showed the more artistic side of you. You did a good job and didn't stray too far from the original.
Simon: Much, much better song choice than the first one. A bit of a lazy arrangement. Limp guitar solo. (Kara interrupts him--how dare he criticize her song pick?? When she finally shuts up, Simon continues speaking to Casey) You sounded very very good. But that song didn't have the wow factor.