You could be right. In general, except for Painted Black, her early performances were good and seemed original (she didn’t care whether she should sing an old hippie song or one that requires soul) and her latter performances gravitated toward more of a pop delivery - too careful. That’s just how it came across to me. Now that she’s out I’m much less interested in who wins.
Two things Siobhan needs to stay away from going forward, her low register (It just doesn't suit her. *FAIL* She thinks it does...) and the Scream! If she would vocally stay mid range on all the songs, she could nail them.
I never really watched anyone's career after Idol especially down 6. I will be very interested to see what happens with her.
Just a quick side note which I find HIGHLY coincidental. I work for a bank and this person presented a check to cash the other day. When I looked at it I noticed the payee name was none other than "Siobhan." It's only the second time I've ever seen that name spelled that way in my life. (dodododo dodododo...)