Alicia Keys is cautiously optimistic.
Siobhan's choice is Whitney Houston's "When You Believe". This could be a soundtrack to an Obama campaign ad. Kind of a mess.
Randy: You probably picked the toughest song of the night. I was just okay for me, baby.
Ellen: I disaggree. More confirmation why you're here.
Kara: Technically it may have been really well done. But this isn't a musical. Still don't know who you are.
Simon: Very old fashioned. Too much happened to quickly. The leaves distracted me. [there are petrified butterflies stuck all over Siobhan, lol, They do look like leaves.
Siobhan gives a long and RAMBLING answer on why she picked this song. She sounds like she's on anti-depressants. "Ijustreallylikedthissong."