Tim Urban
After a gag-inducing video intro, Urban performs "All My Loving", playing guitar. Corny, hoaky, silly. Most of the other singers we've heard tonight are just in a different league.
Randy: You're like in your own category. Was it a good Tim performance? Better than the last couple of weeks. Good Tim performance.
Ellen: Second best performance after "Hallelujah". (liked it)
Kara: You did take some of our criticism. It's hard to listen to what we've been dishing out to you. (also liked it)
Simon: Taking everything into consideration, you did very well. No gimmicks. Just you and the guitar. The song actually sounds very current. You take the criticsm like a man. No whining. You have been given a great opportunity. You handled it very well.
Judges seem to be complimenting him more than the song.