Paige Miles
Miles and Miley.
Paige: "I was starstruck. She has so much experience."
Her song is Phil Collins' "Against All Odds". Ouch. Not good. Reminds us of her awful "Smile" performance a couple weeks ago. Some noticeable sour notes.
Randy: Uh, yo, man, wow. Really honestly? I don't know if your voice is back or what? But that was honestly terrible. Pitch all over the place. Nothing came together at all.
Ellen: I'll start with the postitive--you didn't fall down. Those are high, high heels. You look beautiful. I am now going to turn over the musical critique to Kara and Simon. (laughs)
Kara: I think somewhere along the way you stopped competing. This is the worst vocal I have ever heard from you.
Simon: How do you think you did? (Paige agrees it was pitchy) So we are on the same page. [no pun intended] It was like there were five of you and each one got progressively worse. I think that song just killed you.