You really think they pre-write their critiques?
Why do you say that?
Randy is almost imbecilic this season “Yo, yo, yo...dog” and not much more.
Kara is irritating and Ellen is weird, there’s something very wrong with her.
Simon is great, as usual.
So, what's this about Crystal being diabetic? The way she sat down for the judges tonight looked like back pain to me. I admire her more every week, she's a fighter. Personally, I don't like the Joplin comparison, you know? Hate to see an awesome girl compared to a doped up suicide. I think she's more Joni Mitchell, Mama Cass, early Carly Simon. Modern old school somehow. I love her, and Lily, and Siobhan.
Tonight felt like a memo went out to pick sad songs. These girls are too young to be so serious, and I'm too old to listen to it! Need to hear some "While We're Young and Beautiful", some attitude,you know? Watching Glee right after emphasized the lack of star power in 6 of 8, and the somber mood! Hope they mix it up next week.
Two seasons ago at the point when contestants have to sing two songs Paula started critiquing someone's, can't remember who, I think it was Elliot Yamin, second song that he had not sung yet.
Some of them go to dress rehearsal and take notes. Paula used to do this all of the time.
I’ve been dozing off during the judges’ critiques this season. They are like pre-programmed robots.