Her song is Coldplay's "The Scientist". She's the first contestant to perform with a piano this season. It's a big white Yamaha. She's dressed in white too. Very good voice. But the song is depressing!
Randy: I really liked it. Really waaaay slow. Amazing song. Nice to hear you play the piano. Fell off pitch at the end. I wasn't over the top about it, but I liked it.
Ellen: I liked that you played guitar. You didn't play guitar (laughs) So slow. Way too slow. If I'm home babysitting, can you help me out? Too slow.
Kara: I kinda love you. I do. You have an incredible instrument. You can do a lot with it, but that's the problem. You're all over the place. Figure out who you are real quick.
Simon: I thought it was a smart choice of song. I think what you have to work on, you have become quite corny when you peform. Million times better than last week.
Katelyn: (chatting with Seacrest) Maybe I'm corny because I'm trying too hard. (shrugs and smiles)