Performs James Morrison's "You Give Me Something." Sings sitting on a stool, no instruments. It gets better as it goes along, but it's kind of dull.
Randy: Yo, yo, yo, yo. Amazing song. Honestly, that wasn't the vibe for you tonight. Pitchy all over the place. You are way better than that. I didn't get it, dude.
Ellen: I disagree with Randy. There were some pitch problems, but I liked it. I'm thinking about getting your name tattooed on my neck (Andrew has a name tattooed on his neck--mild chuckle)
Kara: Got to surprise us. You played it too safe. I like when you surprise us.
Simon: Andrew, look. It's just frustrating. The fact that you haven't picked the right song in two weeks is beginning to be a problem. You're never going to look back on that peformance say that was incredible. Disappointed.