Sings "Get Here" by Oleta Adams. He screams some of the words, but overall it's fairly good.
Ellen: I love the way you look. Love that song. Felt like you were pushing a little too much. A couple of times you went out and off. Thought it was a good choice for you. Just relax into the song.
Randy: Such an older song. Trying to do too much vocally with it. Just sing sometimes, you don't have to make so much out of it.
Kara: (she agrees with the others--didn't like it.)
Simon: If you're playing piano in a cocktail bar, it's the kind of a song a 50 year old would request. I think you've blown it. I honestly don't think that was a good enough performance.