Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

To: rustbucket
Gee, war must really be hell after all.

You will note the towns and villages of Hardeeville, Grahamville, Gallisonville, McPhersonville, Barnwell, Blackville, Orangeburg, Lexington, Winnsboro, Camden, and Cheraw were burned.

Well, no. If you read the story it says that barns, warehouses, gin-houses, etc. were burned - economic targets and legitimate targets of war; provisions of every description appropriated or destroyed - it's called foraging and it's no different than the way Lee fed his troops in Pennsylvania; horses and mules carried away - again, legitimate targets for foraging; and sheep, hogs, and cattle were either taken for actual use or shot - again legitimate foraging and/or denying the confederate army food and supplies.

And I'm sure the folks in Chambersburg and Lawrence would have a few stories to compare.

2,110 posted on 08/18/2009 5:05:31 PM PDT by Non-Sequitur
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2095 | View Replies ]


To: Non-Sequitur
If you read the story it says that barns, warehouses, gin-houses, etc. were burned ,,,

Seeing only what you want to see again? You keep losing credibility, if you ever had any. From the link here is the whole sentence (highlighting something critical you missed):

Indignities and outrages were perpetrated upon the persons of the inhabitants; the implements of agriculture were broken; dwellings, barns, mills, ginhouses were consumed; provisions of every description appropriated or destroyed; horses and mules were carried away, and sheep, cattle, and hogs were either taken for actual use or shot down and left behind.

Here is information from other sites on the web about the burning and destruction of those listed SC towns and villages.

Hardeeville: "[sHERMAN'S MARCH THROUGH THE CAROLIINAS] Confederates skirmish at Hardeeville and federals burn the town all night/1865" Link

Barnwell: "The town of Barnwell was burned as was part of Orangeburg and Winnsboro." Link

Grahamville: "Most of the buildings in the town were burned by Gen. Sherman’s troops in 1865." Link

Gallisonville: "burned and left in ruin" Link

McPhersonville: General Logan (Union) to General Howard (Union), January 7 - March 31, 1865 report: "In accordance with your Field Order, Numbers 29, I moved the corps from McPhersonville to Hickory Hill, breaking camp at 7 a.m. Before the rear of my column passed through McPhersonville I regret to inform you that the village was in flames. This was doubtlessly induced by the desertion of their houses by the entire population, for on our entrance into the village not a human being was to be found." Link

Barnwell: "The town of Barnwell was burned as was part of Orangeburg and Winnsboro." Link

Blackville: "On February 12th the army marched out of Blackville, leaving a trail of smoke behind them. A few homes and other buildings survived due to the vigilance and fast work of the villagers." Link

Orangeburg: "Sherman's men push back the Confederate forces at Orangeburg and begin to destroy the railway there and set fire to the town. By the end of the day nearly half the town is destroyed by the fire." Link

Lexington: "The town suffered tremendous loss of buildings in 1865 under the occupation of forces under the command of Gen. Sherman (Lexington was under control of the army guarding the Western Flank of Shermans troops.) Most businesses and homes, the county jail and courthouse and St. Stephen’s Lutheran Church were all burned." Link

Columbia: "The city of Columbia surrenders to Sherman. Union troops occupy the city. A fire breaks out, and by the next day, nearly two-thirds of the city has been destroyed." Link. And: Union Captain George Whitfield Pepper reported in his 1866 book that he met crowds of soldiers returning from Columbia "waving gold watches, handfuls of gold, jewelry, and rebel shinplasters [rb: paper money] in the air, and boasting of having burned the town."

Winnsboro: "During the Civil War, it was looted and partially burned by Union troops in 1865, but many older structures remain." Link. And: "On his march north from the capital city of Columbia in February 1865, General William Tecumseh Sherman had stopped just long enough to burn most of the town, an act that was not soon forgotten." Link. And: ""There were about thirty buildings burned, including dwellings and stores. The Yankees did not seem to care whether a building was occupied or not, but picked out-houses where, in their burning, they would communicate the flames to other premises. Every particle of property burned belonged to private individuals. No public property was destroyed. ... The Yankees also set fire to, and destroyed, the Episcopal Church, situated in the northwestern portion of the town; and while it was burning they took the organ, played upon it, and sang blasphemous songs. Many of the citizens were plundered; wedding rings and mementoes of deceased husbands or parents were stolen as ruthlessly as gold coin would have been. Watches and jewelry were cut from the persons of ladies, and, in some instances, their shoes removed on the pretence of searching for rings." Link

Camden: "Ultimately, like so many other towns in South Carolina, Camden did not escape the wrath of Sherman's men. In February 1865, many of its buildings were once again burned." Link. And: “Most of Camden escaped the torch …” Link. And: "On the 24th of February 1865, during the Civil War, a part of Gen. W. T.Sherman's. army entered Camden and burned stores of tobacco and cotton, and several buildings." Link. And: "In Camden, the Federals burned the railroad depots, a bridge, two thousand bales of cotton, food warehouses, and a flour mill." Link

Cheraw: "Outlying plantations and summer homes are burned, but no in town dwellings or churches are destroyed. Valuables are stolen and there is much vandalism. The official headquarters is the Matheson House. Sherman himself stays on McIver Street. When they leave the town will be destitute, and without food for more than a day or two. Almost the entire business district is destroyed by an accidental Yankee explosion." Link

Williston (not on the list of towns, but I thought I'd include it): "The Union forces then tore up railroad tracks and burned many of Williston’s homes." Link

2,120 posted on 08/18/2009 10:29:51 PM PDT by rustbucket
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2110 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson