Not in my book.
Naysayer fantasies tend to
1. violate Occam’s razor wholesale.
2. virtually insure a TYPE II ERROR fairly routinely.
3. have little understanding or fitting appreciation, respect for piles of evidence well beyond the qualities of evidence that, in court, would convict a murderer to death.
4. be routinely wholesale unscientific and rife with seemingly willfully blind bias and wholesale ignorance.