Adam Lambert
Simon's choice for Adam is U2's "One".
TERRIBLE!! Over-emotional. Gratuitous screaming. What a mess. And he looks like some sort of elf-like creature.
Randy: You're difinitely in the zone. A little for me going off the melody. Don't know if I loved the song that much.
Kara: [she acts like a child, mocking Simon's accent (dead silence from the audience)--she says this is what she meant by making a song your own, etc.]
Paula: One brilliant song. One superb performance. One American idol I'm looking at right now.
Simon: You find a great artist, you find a great song. If you're not in the final next week, it will be one of the be biggest upsets.