Replies

That would mean that the Ellen Tigh we knew was a total facade? Bad plot device.

Not sure. We know that three of the Final Five got killed in the "earth" nuking. Tyrol was incinerated making a nice shadow on a wall. It looks like Ellen died from being crushed when a building fell on top of her, and Tigh when the side of the building blew in.

That means that those three (and, I'd posit, all five) were resurrected at least once already. Ellen died again on New Caprica ... but if she'd already been resurrected once, why wouldn't she be resurrected again? And if resurrected again, why wouldn't she be resurrected with full knowledge of her Cylon heritage, just as D'Anna was resurrected with her sight restored?