[silent_jonny]

Nathaniel Marshall

He sings Meat Loaf's "I Would Do Anything For Love". LOL!

Remember last week, when I said Norman Gentle's performance might be the gayest thing you'll ever see? I take that back.

He looks like he's doing aerobics in 1980's excercise video.

Simon: I think you probably would [do anything for love]. Virging on excruciating. Awful Olvia Newton-John headband. Terrible song choice. You actually are fun.

Randy: Curious song choice. Of all the songs ... You definitely can sing. Don't know what kind of record we would make with you.

Kara: You got a voice. If you want to be taken seriously choose a more serious song. We need to see a different side of you.

[Seacrest runs over to Nathanial's grandmother in the audience--he asks her what she thought of his performance]

Grandma: (shrugs) Yeah. I'm used to his music.

(laughter)

Paula: You know I love you. This song was more like the Boy George version of the song. Have to be real wise choosing your songs.

[TonyWpi]

I’ll bet Jack Bauer could have made that Senator’s aid “talk” if he just played Nathanials audition to him. He’d have broken 1/2 way through it.

[Lil'freeper]

This brunette is indistinguishable from the previous one.

[Majie Purple]

LOL! re: Grandma of n comment!
:)
Again,thanks to You I didn’t miss that reply.

[Wolfstar]

Remember last week, when I said Norman Gentle's performance might be the gayest thing you'll ever see? I take that back. He looks like he's doing aerobics in 1980's excercise video.

I haven't like this kid from the get-go. Anything with studs in his chin and rings in his nose is never gonna appeal to me no matter how he sings.