[Netizen]

On a related note, I don't know why Simon continues to knock singers (like Adam) with a more theatrical style. Talent is talent no matter what type of venue/genre an artist prefers. Because of Simon's odd prejudice against theatrical singers, Adam is going to have to deliver his songs in a very contemporary pop way.

I agree with you, which is why I hope they don't try to make the show be too POP. It's good to keep variety and that means Country, Jazz, Musicals. Quite a few AI contestants have gone on to Broadway and they seem to enjoy it. This is my opinion helps Idol to be a better show because it helps people break into various avenues.

[sirchtruth]

I don't know why Simon continues to knock singers (like Adam) with a more theatrical style.

I tell you why, because they can't sell CD's mainstream. Remember, this is AI not American Theatrical Productions. Simon has to see these people can sell the whole package, not just in America, but all over the world.

Sad, but Styx would so flop today it's not even funny!