I bet you’re thinking of Leneshe Young: http://www.americanidol.com/photos/season_8/hollywood_week/golden_ticket_gallery/37551/
I wonder if the Wild Card winners will be restricted to those who missed the Top 36 cut via a split decision, rather than a unanimous axing? That seems fairer to me, so they probably won’t do it.
I only go by best signing ability. She had it. I don’t often criticize the judges. They have experience I don’t have and there’s always room for disagreement. But I have an ear for music and I was bewildered when she didn’t make it.