[Sir_Ed]

I think she’ll make the judges’ criticizing times last too long. I like watching the singers, then a bit of criticism, then the next singer, and adding a fourth judge means the time they take to criticize and comment will last too long...

Ed

[conservativebabe]

I would agree with that assessment. Let’s just get on with it. She’d have to come up with a unique style all her own that’s entertaining to make us want to sit through a 4th judges comments.

[silent_jonny]

I think she’ll make the judges’ criticizing times last too long.

Maybe, or it will give the other judges less room to ramble. Most of what Paula says is meaningless anyway, LOL. And if a fourth judge means we'll hear a little less shameless pimping from Randy, then I'm all for it :)