Man, you know less about Hinduism that you do about science.
That is true enough, considering I am a credentialed, practicing scientist, while my knowledge of Hinduism comes only from the books I've read about it. But tell us - what exactly do you think was wrong (specifically) with the argument? I mean, surely you can do better than hand-waving, right?
Oh, and by the way, what did you say your degree was in again?