[Netizen]

I think Carly tried to really push her voice on the song and she went from controlled to out of control screaming in parts.

I agree completely.

[b9]

Perhaps the main problem with Andrew Lloyd Weber night was that his songs are meant for actors.
Even the best performances that night seemed to be imitations of actors, IMO.

ALW hired Gerard Butler to play the Phantom in the movie because of his acting ability, not his singing. Thought that was interesting.