I don’t mind them doing it for 1 week, its not like they sing songs from muscials every week. I don’t want to listen to pop and rap. They have crap like Mariah Scarey and Leona screamer every week and they will lose tons of viewers. They already figure that Archuleta’s votes are coming from the 50+ and under 12 age brackets and he doesn’t even sing pop or anything contemporary!
I think that people tune in to see the Chris Daughtrys, the Kelly Clarksons, the Carrie Underwoods (not Reuben - I - look - like - I - need - a- bib and - baby food - Stoddard).
And I think that’s why this season is boring. Is David A. going to be a top twenty seller? Syesha? No.
That makes for boredom. Simon may irritate some, but I agree with him most of the time.