[Clint N. Suhks]

From the spoiler comments, we know that during rehearsals there are “fake” judges. So perhaps someone already scripted the comments for Paula based on rehearsals. If that is the case, Idol just exposed itself big time.

There is no other explanation.

[ken5050]

Wrong my firend, sorry..but there is another perfectly reasonable explanation for Paula's observation that David Cook was "fantastic.."

Go ahead..use your imagination..(g)