BTW..Monchici's "Sweet Carolina" was AWFUL..terrible arrangement, and his voice was all over the palce..
Maybe someone that tivo'd the show can clarify something for me. I thought Paula said she didn't care for Jason's second performance, yet when she was remindedthat Jason hadn't sung a second song yet, I thought she tried to explain that she got it confused with David Cook's song. The problem with this is that I thought she liked David Cosk's performance.
So, if she did just get Cook's performance confused and attribute it to Jason, whouldn't Jason have gotten a favorable review on his second song which was actually Cook?
Her story just didn't mesh for me.
From the spoiler comments, we know that during rehearsals there are “fake” judges. So perhaps someone already scripted the comments for Paula based on rehearsals. If that is the case, Idol just exposed itself big time.
No, Paula just can't take good notes.
Cook went second, and so she got confused reading back her notes, thinking that they applied to Jason's second performance (he went first). Apparently it's hard to both take and then decipher notes you take when you're plastered.
BTW..Monchici's "Sweet Carolina" was AWFUL..terrible arrangement, and his voice was all over the palce..
He's clearly not ready for prime-time. I'm seeing more weaknesses in his voice, and his performance skills seem to have gotten worse, not better, as the competition goes on.