[silent_jonny]

How would you compare those first two seasons with the others seasons? Do you think they are all equal or were there improvements made?

The first season was just odd. Idol was only a low-budget Summer show then--it didn't have all the production values and celebrity mentors that it's had since then.

And Seacrest and Dunkleman looked like a gay couple--LOL!

As far as contestants go, they were lucky to get Kelly Clarkson and Tamyra Gray. The rest had no business being there.

Season 2 was a huge improvement. Idol began to look more like it does now, with a much better crop of singers.

[Republican Red]

The lineup tonight has Jason in the "dredded" first spot. However, according to American Idol legend, the #2 spot is the death spot.

Going around different AI forums:

Anyways, remember that tonight on top 5 night, there is that "cursed" number 2 spot. Everyone who gets it goes home.

Season 1- RJ
Season 2- Trenyce
Season 3- George
Season 4- Scott
Season 5- Paris
Season 6 (they went from 6 to 4 cause of IGB but Chris Rich was 2nd on what would have been top 5 night

[retrokitten]

{running in doing a girly shriek} I MADE IT!!!

[silent_jonny]

Ladies and Gentlemen ...

Neil Diamond

"I'm not a fan of Mr. Diamond--even though I own all of his albums. He doesn't sing for me or my campaign. He's not the same entertainer that I knew 20 years ago."

Click Here for Pics & Bios of the Top 12

Click Here for Pics & Bios of the Top 24

Continued Prayers Requested for Ladyinred

As always, if you want on or off this ping list, just let me know :)