Eventhough Simon tells people, "It's a singing compitition," that's not all it is. The whole package is preferred, and Brooke brings something to the table which is marketable to more than ONE segment of the population.
One thing she definately needs to do is STFU when the judges are critiquing her performance.
Agreed. I focus most on singing talent and on-stage poerformance. And I rated her lower in both. But I see how she’s getting votes from many. I’m not the typical demographic and I don’t do power voting on my text messaging. LOL!