Replies

I agree. My two bottom singers based upon performance throughout: Brooke and Jason.

What is so interesting about FR is that while your lowest two Brook and Jason...they are my top two. lol. Maybe they show different shows to different folks. I love that we are all different though. It makes these threads fun.

I can be more specific and technical. Jason has sung several ballads where he could not perform the high note registry. There was one week where he was so pitchy I thought he might as well just leave the competition on his own. His Rainbow this week was flat. I believe it's because he arranged the song to avoid having to go up there, you know, over the rainbow with the high notes. But hey, the judges love him and so do the little girls who mass vote on their Hello Kitty cell phones. So, it must be me.

Simon and Randy criticize someone every week for being boring and not stretching their song selection. I don't know why that doesn't apply to Brooke. Her range seems very narrow and nothing special. She picks safe flat songs and doesn't get called for it. I try to focus on singing, but Brooke is irritating with her cutesy behavior alternating with her anxiety attacks. She has a soap opera story going on every week and I think it's a sympathy act to get votes. She's about two weeks overdue for my money.

The guy who got dumped consistently demonstrated week after week a strong voice and ranged from hard rock to blues. He showed he could move on stage something neither of the other two have done. He'll be around fronting a band when Jason is back flipping burgers and Brooke is on the front porch rocking her fourth baby wondering why she didn't make it after all the times Simon flirted with her starting in the auditions.