[silent_jonny]

Jason Castro

I don't know this song ("Fragile"), but it's a lot better than Ramelie's screech fest.

Castro is playing the accoustic guitar again, sitting on a stool while he sings. This works for him.

Randy: Dude, I love that song. Very good choice. Very nice and pleasant. Still waiting to see that jump-out vocal performance.

Paula: Those songs are your niche. I agree we didn't see anything different, that made us say 'wow'. But that's who you are.

Simon: Jason, I think you've had two bad weeks. You need to start taking this more seriously. That was the equivalent to someone playing outside a subway station. You are potentially a winner, but you're not going to win if you keep doing that week after week. I'm telling you.

[Wolfstar]

Simon: Jason, I think you've had two bad weeks. You need to start taking this more seriously.

Jason's gnats are SO disappointed.

[MOgirl]

Hello FRiend,

Am I the only one that thought that he looked stoned?

Bet I'm not.....

MOgirl

[Yaelle]

Marking my place for later. Since I watch Idol so much later than you all do, I read the thread the next day for fun.

Starting to predict exactly what Simon would say before he says it - on viewing this show I actually predicted Simon’s “very clever song choice” for Kristie. It kept her on the show for another week without anything to do with her singing.

Cook is the hottest talent on the show now, IMO. I would have paid to see his last night’s performance. Wonder what you all think - will read more later.