As a Christian, I’m more concerned about Jewish attitudes towards my culture today.
There are some like Savage and Medved and Lapin who are quite warm and many Conervative and Orthodox but most Reformed don’t much cotton to Christian Conservatism
even here.
Given our supersupport for Israel, this vexes me. Plenty of we social conservatives support Israel for cultural reasons...not religious.
That I am not on the same page as most American Jews is just how it is....probably since the early 1900s
Issues with people on FR you should take up with them. Other than that, this shouldn't vex you, Israel isn't necessarily the top issue for most Jews, misdirected social concerns are.