"I think Finnerty is the most at risk too. I worry about what a judge will do because there's a tendency to want to make someone the "fall guy" in these things."
But I also hear that his alibi is even better than Seligmann's.
And if ALL THREE can't be placed together with the AV for the rape, then the rape story collapses. I think all of Finnerty's time can be accounted for and there is never a moment when he was out of the sight of others, and could have had the opportunity to commit the rape (absent the famous Duke cloaking device, of course).
I think Finnerty has a great alibi too. He is clearly innocent. I just worry that his case won't get thrown out pre-trial because he doesn't have as strong an argument on the photo line-ups as Seligmann and Evans. I can't imagine he could ever be convicted.