[js1138]

It's not simplified. It's wrong. It bears no resemblance to any scenario outside the mind of a creationist.

If you can't state your opponent's position, you can't join the debate.

Let's see you figure out what's wrong with the "simplification." If you can, I will respond. I don't believe you, or any of the evolution critics can write a simple paragraph describing how an actual biologist would describe this evolution scenario.

[DungeonMaster]

What's wrong with it. Remember, it's intentionally simplified and leaned in favor of evolution. Keep that in mind and tell me the flaw.