He thought they looked fine... didn't take a lot off, just rasped them, didn't really want to entertain the idea of shoeing her. I asked "Does she need shoes?" He said "Nope".
Chatty guy. :~)
LOL.
Well, I said it earlier, I'll say it again. Unless someone has ridden her, or any horse for that matter, I don't see how they can say one way or another. IMO, it depends on how much they gimp, more then if their foot chips/wears. ecurbh is the one that should decide, not you, not the farrier:).
Becky