Something strange about Seligmann's selection is that he was one of the players identified by the captains as not being present at the party, but she picked him anyway. I'm curious if Seligmann perhaps responded to McFadden's email, or something simliar that places him at the party. If the investigators truly believed he wasn't at the party, then I imagine they would have simply ignored his ID like they did the first person she ID'd.
If you think about it, think about the suspicions of the Nifong and the investigators. These 46 guys are standing as a block, some as young as 18, they've played tricks on them (telling them player A implicated you, and the e-mail sent from a player's account) and no one caved. They were told how their careers would be over and so on, no one caved.
Who would be able to keep these young guys in line like that? Who would engender such loyalty?
I'm sure that is another reason why 23 year David Evans that was voted unamimously as Team Captain was a strong suspect.
And there are valid reasons why Lineups are supposed to be administered by someone totally outside the investigation that truly doesn't know fillers from suspects. Fillers - that's another violation entirely.