Quick rating:
1. Eliot 2. bucky 3. Kellie 4. taylor 5. mandisa 6. Chris 7. lisa 8. Paris 9. Katherine 10. Ace
This was by far the absolute worst Idol ever.
Switch around Chris and Kellie.
My rating is pretty close, except I'd put McPhee up a lot higher...
1) Elliott Mr. Tumnus
2) McPhee
3) Bucky
4) Mandisa
5) Taylor
6) Chris
7) Kellie May
8) Lisa
9) G'Ace
10)Paris
You list looks pretty good, although I don't think Katherine should be that far down. There were several worse performances. I do think Ace is in real trouble.
1. Elliot
2. Taylor
3. Mandisa
4. Paris
5. Katherine
6. Chris
7. Bucky
8. Ace
9. Kellie
10. Lisa