[TonyWpi]

"We're getting to the point where a bad week will kill ya."

So true!!

Mandisa's problem was doing a Shania tune. You can't sing Shania unless you have her pipes and are "smokin' hot!"

[Feiny]

Mandisa has a better voice than Shania.

[Netizen]

And dial idol was dead on this week with Mandisa going home, and the only switch needed is between Chris and Katharine for their whole list to be right.(top 3, middle 3, and bottom three) At some point their numbers had to start being right.

1	Taylor Hicks	37.333	1.72	-
2	Katharine McPhee	28.589	1.836	-
3	Kellie Pickler	28.135	1.842	-
4	Chris Daughtry	26.915	1.857	-
5	Ace Young	23.787	1.897	-
6	Bucky Covington	23.113	1.905	-
7	Paris Bennett	19.035	1.955	-
8	Elliott Yamin	14.184	2.013	-
9	Mandisa	13.177	2.025