[silent_jonny]

But I'm curious what you think now that we've gotten to know them and their abilities a bit better.

I still think the first season was the worst :)

Kelly and Tamyra were the only people that year who had any talent whatsoever (but I do give an honorable mention to Niki McKibbon because I think she really tried--and she's still trying).

This year's remaining nine have varying degrees of talent, but they all have at least some talent. And they all seem to know exactly what they want to do.

Bucky and Pickler, Country.

Chris, Rock.

Elliot, Jazz.

Taylor, Soul.

Ace, Pop.

And Mandisa, Paris and McPhee all want to be the next big diva.

This is the most focused group that AI has ever had, IMO, and if they were given the right material, each of them could produce a decent album. Even Ace :)

But I have to admit that this group is failing to connect with the audience. They don't seem as likable as past finalists. Maybe because they know the show isn't a joke, that winning means everything for their careers. But as far as just talent goes, I think this is one of the best groups that Idol has ever assembled.

[Wolfstar]

But I have to admit that this group is failing to connect with the audience. They don't seem as likable as past finalists. Maybe because they know the show isn't a joke, that winning means everything for their careers.

Thanks, Jonny. I always appreciate your opinion. Maybe that's exactly what the problem is.