Ace was fantastic...I think all you guys are intimidated befause he is so fabulous looking. He's talented...it's incredibly hard to sing like he did tonight and he did a great job. To me, he's shown the most versatility. You're all showing your age with Taylor...HE'S TOO OLD TO BE THE AMERICAN IDOL. GO ACE GO ACE GO ACE!!!! also Chris and Elliott. But I have to say Thank God this year there are some great male singers. IMO, the first year of the great male singers.
With age comes wisdom, judgement, taste... ;^)
I thought Taylor stole the show tonight. He exudes such joy when he is singing. He makes everybody feel good.
Ace annoyed me with that falsetto. A very pretty white boy trying to sing black. I hated that Michael Jackson song. All I could think of was Jackson singing it to little boys (his victims)..."You give me butterflies." UGH!
I was disappointed with Elliott tonight. I hope he picks something more upbeat next week.
Gedeon is very young...I think his voice will mature beautifully.
Chris is consistently good.
Bucky belongs on Country Idol (or whatever it's called). He doesn't articulate. Bet he can't spell it either.
Bottom two--the Irish tenor,Covais, maybe he can get a gig on PBS. And Will...cute but not exceptional in any way.
I think your dreamy eyes for him have taken away from your ability to hear. He butchered that song. He missed most of the falsetto notes and just murdered the rest.
Unfortunately, there are a ton of people like you that fall for marketing and packaging and don't give a rip about musical ability and artistry. That is the the tru downfall of this show is that it is a popularity contest aimed at doe eyed tween girls. But they buy the records so the producers could give a crap about finding the next great artist. Just show 'em the money and they'll keep churning out cookie cutter, boring, unoriginal, formulaic money. They just love people like you. More power to them for proving P.T. Barnum was right and making a boat load of cash in the process...
Just my humble opinion of course...;-)
Geez, Hildy.
It's impossible to be intimidated by a guy that sings nothing but George Michael and Michael Jackson tunes.
You can't seem to get past their looks: Mandisa is too fat, Hicks is too old, etc. Are you that superficial?
I spit up in my mouth a little....