Some of the constestants never stood a chance against the others. This year its like they had two levels of performers. If they do the same thing next year, I won't bother watching. In my opinion, it's better when all the contestants have a chance, instead of sticking a 'ringer or ringers' in there.
Anyone can do a recording now ---- all you need is a few dollars and you can lay down some tracks. Whether it gets any airplay or sells is a completely different story.
If Carrie was on a recording, but not the star, it wouldn't make any difference in the way I feel.
I understand your position on the levels of performers, but just having a recording wouldn't just be the ticket. Just MHO.