[GraniteStateConservative]

So your point is, we shouldn't be impressed by Bo's awesome a capella rendition of "Within a Dream" because he's sung it before?

No, just that part of the sizzle of it was that it was such a dangerous thing to do. People were going, "Wow!" before he even really started the song. I think it affected how people looked at the performance. Do you not agree that it would be much more amazing if he'd never done it before a capella, and I think that's what a lot of people thought-- that they were seeing the debut of this performance?

[b9]

Do you not agree that it would be much more amazing if he'd never done it before a capella

No, I do not agree.

It just sounds like sour grapes from a die hard Carrie fan.